If stocks wind up the decade having returned 8% a year since the low in March 2009, the corresponding 20-year return would equal the worst 20-year period for stocks in history, 1929 to 1949.
In other words, the longer than 1-year holding period, the return of 100% of the initial capital to the limited partners, and the full and equal risk that managers take alongside their limited partners (plus it is common for the managers to put some of their own money into the fund) all justify carried interest treatment as a capital gain.