Mr Tyndall had planned to a send a copy of the report to the General Medical Council, the body which regulates doctors, because "Mr Y seemed disinclined to believe he had anything to learn".
Instead, to judge by the most comprehensive study on the reliability of forensic evidence to date, the error rate is more than 10% in five categories of analysis, including fiber, paint and body fluids. (Meaning: When the expert says specimen X matches source Y, there's a 10% probability he's wrong.) DNA and fingerprints are more reliable but still not foolproof.