Critics say PRs enjoy the benefits of citizenship without all the responsibilities, such as national service for men (first-generation PRs are generally exempt).

ECONOMIST: Singapore and immigration

At least without renouncing American citizenship.

FORBES: How New Offshore Bank Rules Will Affect Americans

Advocates say without that path to citizenship, there would be no incentive for illegal immigrants to come forward and register with authorities.

NPR: Kennedy, McCain Introduce Immigration, Guest Worker Bill