We will make our decisions on the basis of the total evidence we collect, not on the basis of today's headlines."
VOA: standard.2009.04.21
This means that on average, most people would be better off skipping the insurance and investing the money on their own since the insurance companies pay out less than the total amount that they collect plus the investment returns.
Considering the call seller will also collect the premium, that would drive a total return of 12.09% if the stock gets called away at the July expiration (before broker commissions).
Considering the call seller will also collect the premium, that would drive a total return of 17.87% if the stock gets called away at the July expiration (before broker commissions).