Or the physicalist can only do a rotten job of explaining, like demon theory did?
或者,物理主义者只能,提供一个很蹩脚的解释,就像恶魔理论那样。
And then the question is, "What can the physicalist say in response?"
接下来的问题是,物理主义者能如何回应?
Now, the best possible response would be for the physicalist to say, "Here's how to build a machine that can be conscious in this sense."
物理主义者们现在,能做出的最好的回答就是,从这个意义上去理解,就能造出一台,具有意识的机器。
Is there some feature that the physicalist can't explain and so we need to appeal to something extra-physical to explain it?
是否存在物理主义者不能解释的这种特性,使得我们不得不诉诸于,某些超物理的东西来解释
Or the physicalist can only do a rotten job of explaining, like demon theory did?
或者,物理主义者只能,提供一个很蹩脚的解释,就像恶魔理论那样
You might say, "Look, the physicalist can't tell us that, because all the physical parts are still there when you've got the corpse, at least if it's a fresh corpse before the decay has set in.
你可能会说,你看,物理主义不会告诉我们那些的,因为尸体所有的,身体器官部分都还存在,至少对于还未腐烂的尸体而言是这样的
应用推荐