I'd be happy to discuss with you, outside class, at greater length my favorite theories as to where the argument goes wrong and why I think it goes wrong in Descartes' case as well.
White gained slight turn from a ball that was pitched on a lengthoutside off stump and Tendulkar, attempting to run it down to third man, handed Hayden a straightforward catch at slip.
Broad, summoned up to bowl the fifth over after Tim Bresnan and Ryan Sidebottom had shared the new ball, bowled a delivery just back of a lengthoutside off-stump, seaming away a fraction.