That was short of the 500 hour threshold that is the gold standard of material participation.

FORBES: Even Real Estate Salesman Has Trouble With Passive Loss Exception

However, the real estate professional special rules that apply when rental activities are aggregated to achieve material participation status suggest trade or business treatment.

FORBES: Should Landlords be Filing 1099s for Service Providers?

You should note that she would have had a material participation problem with the the New Jersey property due to her failure to make the election.

FORBES: Real Estate Professional Status - Becoming More Important - Very Hard To Prove