The 18-year-old Watt, making his first appearance in Europe's top club competition, made it 2-0 after veteran midfielder Xavi failed to cut out a long clearance by Celtic keeper Fraser Forster.
Welbeck had earlier seen a glancing header flash wide of the post, but when Gerrard seized on a clearance 40 yards from goal, he delivered a spectacular cross that cut out two defenders and dropped on Carroll's forehead.
Watford defender Adrian Mariappa made a sharp clearance after Loach had spilled a Taarabt free-kick, while Taarabt played a superb cut-back that picked out Faurlin, who had time to place his shot but wastefully drilled his effort over from 14 yards as the opening half ended goalless.