Malvo is awaiting a preliminary hearing in juvenile court next week, but his case is widely expected to be moved to circuit court for trial later this year or 2004.
The government appealed the case to a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit, which reversed the trial court's decision, holding that reasonable suspicion wasn't required.
During deliberations, which capped a five-day trial in Sauk County Circuit Court, dozens of farmers, food-rights activists and Hershberger family members filled the courthouse, sharing raw milk from Mr. Hershberger's farm.