The use of a sufficiently robust basket would result in a balanceoferrors as variations in one direction in some commodities cancel out variations in the opposite direction in others.
In seeking to balance the supposed necessity of finality against the obvious need to protect the innocent from all-too-frequent errors, the case probes the viability and scope of the constitutionally-protected writ of habeas corpus, the procedural device for reviewing otherwise final judgments based on newly-discovered evidence.