Courts have concluded that no one should be convicted of perjury without demonstrating that the testimony in question was in fact false, that the person testifying knew it to be false, and that the testimony involvedanissue that is material to the case, one that could influence the outcome of the matter one way or the other.
One of those private e-mails at issueinvolvedan exchange between Martin and Vickie Patton, the General Counsel for the Environmental Defense Fund, regarding an arranged meeting with him.