Simmias says we can't conclude that the soul is indestructible because we should not believe the subconclusion 4 invisible things can't be destroyed.
他说我们不能得出结论说,灵魂不朽或几乎不朽或其他什么,因为我们不该相信,4这个结论4,即无形的东西不可毁灭。
But of course,nobody here is screaming, from which we can conclude none of us really do believe, fundamentally,deep down,that we're going to die.
但当然现在在场没人在尖叫,那我们得出结论,我们中没有人,从根本上相信自己会死。
So, in fact, it is true, it is in fact true, so we can conclude that 2 dominates in fact, we can do a bit better than that we can say strictly dominates 1.
事实的确如此,我们可以得出结论立场2优于立场1,或者更进一步说,立场2严格的优于立场1
And then if 5 is true that the soul is really invisible, we are entitled to conclude 6 The soul can't be destroyed.
然后如果5正确,即灵魂确实无形,我们有资格得出6这个结论6,灵魂不会毁灭。
But according to the no branching rule, we can't yet conclude that I'm the same person as the person that was lecturing to you on Tuesday.
但根据无分支规则,我们还不能总结说,我跟星期二,给你们上课的人为同一人。
So even though it's true that some kind of recycling takes place, we can't conclude that everything that's now a part of me will continue to exist afterwards.
即使有一些部件会被循环利用,但我们不能断定,组成我们身体的每一部件都会死后永存
If some invisible things can be destroyed, and harmony is an example of that, then, by golly, it's going to follow that we can't conclude from the invisibility of the soul that the soul can't be destroyed.
如果有形的东西可以毁灭,和声是这样的一个例子,那么接下来我们就无法得出,灵魂是无形的,无法毁灭的。
应用推荐