What better suggestion is there for what we could point to as the metaphysical glue, ? the key to personal identity?
还有什么更好的东西,我们可以用来,作为形而上粘质,作为人格同一性的关键?
Because when we've thought about the first case, the intuition seemed to be, ah,personality's the key to personal identity.
因为当我们思考案例一,得到的直觉似乎是,人格是个人认同感的关键。
But when we thought about the second case, the intuition seems to be, body is the key to personal identity.
但当思考案例二时,得到的直觉似乎是,肉体是个人认同感的关键。
And particular, how should we run that if we think about the body as the key ? to personal identity?
特别是,当我们认为肉体是,人格同一性的关键时,对此我们又如何解释?
And so that's the part of the brain that's the key part of a body for the purpose of personal identity.
所以大脑,这个身体最关键的部位,就是人格统一性的关键。
Even if there're no souls, we don't have to say that the key to personal identity is the sameness of the body.
即使没有灵魂的存在,我们也不用,肯定人格同一性的关键在于,同样的肉体。
And having the very same body is the key to to personal identity. It's not the same person.
而拥有同样肉体才是人格同一性的,关键,现在的并非原来那个人。
As we could have same personality without literally same brain, if personality is the key to personal identity, that would still be me.
我们可以拥有同样的人格,不需要同样的大脑,如果人格是人格同一性的关键的话,那个人还是我。
The key to personal identity, according to the soul theory of personal identity the key to personal identity is having the same soul.
人格同一性的关键,根据灵魂理论来说,人格同一性的关键,在于有同一个灵魂。
Well--what we think is very important here is the personality, why don't we just say-- the key to personal identity is the personality.
我们认定最重要的是,人格,我们就可以说-,人格同一性的关键在于人格。
Last time we turned to the question of what the metaphysical key to personal identity might be.
上次我们谈到,对于人格同一性的概念而言,形而上学的关键是什么。
So body is the key to personal identity, we don't have to worry about the fact that we are constantly gaining and losing items.
因此肉体是人格同一性的关键,不必担心,肉体不停地新增或失去什么微粒。
We've distinguished three different views as to the secret or key to personal identity across time.
我们陆续已经辨别了三种不同的,关于个人认同感关键的理论观点。
And personality theory, key to be-- key to personal identity is having the very same personality.
人格论-,人格同一性的关键在于,同样的人格。
The key to personal identity, according to the soul view, is having the very same soul.
根据灵魂论,人格同一性的关键,是有相同的灵魂。
Even though there are souls, they may not be the key to personal identity, maybe sameness of the body is the key to personal identity.
即使灵魂存在,它们也不是人格同一性的,关键,也许同样的肉体,才是人格同一性的关键。
Rock believed in souls, he just didn't think they were the key to personal identity.
洛克相信灵魂论,但他认为,这并不是人格统一性的关键。
The key to personal identity according to the soul view is having the same soul.
根据灵魂存在观点,人格同一性的关键在于有同一个灵魂。
We could instead say, the key to personal identity is the sameness of the personality.
我们可以说,人格同一性的关键在于,同样的人格。
Bare survival of my soul,even though that is the key to personal identity-- if it is--bare survival of my soul doesn't give me what I want.
仅有我灵魂的存活,即便是个人认同感的关键-,也并没有给予我,我想要的任何东西。
I'm inclined to think that the key to personal identity is having the same body, as long as there's no branching,as long as there's no splitting.
我倾向于觉得个人认同感取决于同样的身体,前提是没有分支和分裂。
And yet for all that dualists could consistently say, still same soul as not the key to personal identity, same personality is the key to personal identity.
所有的二元论者都可以坚持认为,同样的灵魂并非,人格同一性的关键,同样的人格,才是人格同一性的关键。
The first, approach is this that we considered was the soul theory of personal identity, the key to being the same person is having the same soul.
首先,我们设置的前提是,人格同一性的灵魂存在论,成为同一个人的关键在于,拥有同样的灵魂。
That's gonna be our guide to deciding what's the key to personal identity.
他就能指导我们找到关于,什么是人格同一性关键的指导思想。
But that's not the key to personal identity, according to the soul view.
但根据灵魂论,那都不是人格同一性的关键。
And so when the personality theorist says the key to personal identity is the same personality. They don't mean literally the very same set of believes and desires.
所以当人格论专家说道,人格同一性的关键在于,同样的人格时,他们指的不是,一成不变的一系列信仰和渴望。
The metaphysical key to personal identity is having the very same soul.
人格同一性的形而上关键,在于有同一个灵魂。
If you find this argument convincing, what it's an argument for is the claim that even if souls do exist, they may not be the key to personal identity.
如果你信服这个观点,我们要证明的是,就算灵魂真的存在,也不是人格同一性的关键。
We were raising a difficulty for the personality theory of personal identity according to which the key to being the same person is having the very same ongoing,evolving personality.
我们给判断个人认同感的人格理论,也就是说判断是否是同一个人取决于,是否具有同样的形成中的人格这理论。
What's the key or the nature or the basis of personal identity?
什么是个人同一性的关键,本质或基础
应用推荐