That follows then that this intuition suggests that what I find intuitively plausible is the personality theory of personal identity.
也就是说这个直觉暗示的是,我认为人格理论在直觉上是合理的。
Because I don't just want it to be me, I want to have there be somebody that's me with my personality.
因为我想要的不只是我的身份,而是需要带有我的人格的人存在。
She can't get in to heaven anyway. So she says: "Dear Mary: I am a bastard and a bastard shall not enter the kingdom of heaven as we all know. But I have this personality that makes boys follow me.
反正她是怎样也升不进天堂的,所以,她写道,亲爱的玛丽:,我是一个私生子,我不能进入天堂,众所周知,但我拥有吸引男孩的独特个性。
I don't know whether the average undergrad at the University of Arizona just has a sunny personality or whether they "Spent too long in the sun."
亚利桑那大学的毕业生,是都很阳光呢,还是他们"在阳光下晒得太久了"
So, for instance, there's no evidence that oral and anal characteristics, the personality characteristics I talked about about being needy versus being stingy relate in any interesting way to weaning or toilet training.
比如,并没有证据表明,我们之前所讲到的,粘人的口腔期人格特征,和吝啬的肛门期人格特征,与断奶或是如厕训练之间,存在任何关系。
unless the brain is not good enough, as I said, what counts good enough are not enough to keep the personality.
除非大脑不是完好的,不够完好,无法储存,完整的人格。
But since I don't believe in souls, I want to choose between the body view and the personality view.
但因为我不相信灵魂,我想从身体理论和人格理论中选择。
So again the point I was just emphasizing was even if we accept the personality theory, this doesn't threaten our being physicalists.
我刚才再次强调的一点,即使我们接受了人格论,也不会和物理主义学者的身份冲突。
When I think about what I want, it's not just that there be somebody at the tail end of an evolving personality.
我所想要的,不是在进化的人格的最后,变成另一个人。
According to the personality theory or the revised personality theory, that's because I've got the same personality.
根据人格理论,或修正的人格理论,那是因为我具有相同的人格。
Once you give me that, give me that there's somebody there with my similar personality, I think that may be all that matters.
一旦你给了我,给我一个有着和我相似人格的人存在,我想就足够了。
So on the personality theory, I did not exist when that fertilized egg came into being, when the egg and the sperm joined.
所以在人格理论上,卵子受精的时候我还不存在,卵子和精子结合时。
Well,if we take the personality theory,we have to say, my body's still alive,but I'm not still alive.
如果我们接受人格理论,认为我的肉体依然存活,但我已经死亡。
When my body goes one way and my personality goes another way,where do I go?
当它们有分歧,我会怎么选择?
Both in terms of body functions and personality functions, I'm just a corpse.
生理功能和人格功能都停止的时候,我只是一具尸体了。
Shelly Kagan Since there's no competitor,and I've got the personality,I'm Shelly Kagan.
既然没有竞争对手,我具有正确人格,我就是。
That's what the personality theory should say and I said it doesn't seem like a crazy thing to say if we only had the guy in New York.
按照人格理论应该是如此,这么说也不算疯狂,前提是只有这个纽约家伙。
On the personality view,I don't exist when I'm a corpse.
在人格理论角度,我作为尸体时并不存在。
And I stipulated that it is the same evolving personality.
我假设就是相同的进化中的人格。
I want it to be me with my personality.
我想要带有我的人格的自己。
What you wanted--at least what I want, I invite you to ask yourself whether you want the same thing-- what I want is not just survival, but survival with the same personality.
你想要的,至少我想要的,你们也问问自己你们是不是想要这个-,我想要的不仅仅是存活,而是带有同样的人格存活。
If we make--If we solve the problem of boredom setting in with progressive memory loss and radical personality changes, maybe boredom won't set in, but it's not anything that I especially want for myself.
如果用持续失忆,和剧烈人格变化来解决无聊的问题,也许不会产生无聊,但那不是我特别想做的事。
I'm putting Freud here but what I mean is well-known defenders of Freud will make some claims like: adult personality traits are shaped by the course of psychosexual development; all dreams are disguised wish fulfillment; psychoanalysis is the best treatment for mental disorders.
我虽然在这里说的是弗洛伊德,其实指的是那些著名的弗洛伊德的拥护者,他们会总结出这样的观点:,成年人的人格特质,是在性心理的发展过程中形成的;,所有的梦境都是愿望满足的伪装;,精神分析是治疗心理障碍的最佳手段。
And I've drawn a lot of different distinctions about what would you say if you're a personality theorist to deal with this?
我也提出了很多,作为人格理论者或肉体理论者时?
Here's what I think is the best revision available to fans of the personality theory.
对于人格理论的支持者,下面说说我认为的最好的修正。
We'd being saying on the personality theory, I don't exist,but I'm alive.
在人格理论下,我们说,我不存在,但依然存活。
When did I begin to exist on the personality theory?
根据人格理论,我是什么时候开始存在的呢?
I think,in fact,the personality theory's got to be rejected.
我觉得实际上人格理论是该被否决。
Now,if the Michigan guy hadn't been there, what I would have done, if I believed in the personality theory or when I believe in the personality theory, is say Oh look,Napoleon--reincarnated in New York.
如果密西根家伙不曾出现在那里,那么我就会,假如我相信人格理论的话,我便会说,看,拿破仑在纽约转生了。
I want to survive with the same personality.
我想要带着相同的人格生存。
应用推荐