But it's the very same case.It can't be that in one of them, follow the body and the other one,follow personality.
但这是完全相同的案例不可能说在其中一个案例里,追随肉体,但在另一个里追随人格。
Ah,says the soul theorist, Follow the soul--unless the soul splits, Shelly Kagan in which case neither of them is Shelly Kagan.
灵魂理论者说,跟随灵魂,除非灵魂分裂,那样他们就都不是。
In the special case where there's splitting, even if you follow the brain,not good enough.
在特殊情况下,分裂产生,跟随大脑这一原则就不够适用了。
Well, that's right and of course we don't have any good reason to follow Plato when he says it must be the case that the soul exsited prior to birth.
这是正确的,而且我们没什么好的理由,跟随柏拉图的观点,即,灵魂存在于出生之前。
So in the ordinary case,no splitting,follow the brain.
所以在通常的情况下,不会有分裂。
应用推荐