Imagine a world in which Kagan exists, but Shelly doesn't exist, because nobody in the world is named Shelly.
想象在一个世界里卡根存在,而薛立不存在,因为这个世界里面没人叫薛立
Of course, that doesn't mean that in the real world one of them does exist and the other one doesn't.
当然,这并不意味着,在现实世界里面其中一个存在,而另一个不存在
hello c So if I say hello.c which actually doesn't exist in here hi1 c but hi1.c does, you'll find it alphabetically.
如果没看到,那就是。
But it doesn't exist in a systemic space; it exists in an unfolding time, right?
但这并不存在于一个系统化的空间里;,而是打开的时间里,是吗?
It's right opposite Constantinople-- that doesn't exist, Istanbul.
就在君士坦丁堡对面,现在我们叫它,伊斯坦布尔
All right,so on the body view,I exist here, but I'm not alive,so it doesn't give me what matters.
好了,在肉体理论角度,我存在于此,但我并不是活着的,这不是我想要的关键。
You can't have a world in which the Morning Star doesn't exist but the Evening Star does.
不可能在某个世界里,晨星不存在,而昏星却存在
Well, maybe I did imagine a world in which the Morning Star exists and the Evening Star doesn't exist, but maybe imagining doesn't mean it's possible.
或许我想象这一个,晨星存在,但昏星不存在的世界,但也许想象并不表示可能
And if it is just one thing, you could tell a story in which it exists; you could tell a story in which it doesn't exist.
所以,如果它只是一个物体,你只能说它存在,或是不存在
But you can't tell a story in which it exists and doesn't exist.
但你不能说,它既存在又不存在
So there couldn't be a world in which the Evening Star exists, but the Morning Star doesn't, because that would be a world in which Venus exists and Venus doesn't exist.
所以不可能有一个世界昏星存在,而晨星不存在,因为那意味着在那个世界里金星存在,而同时金星不存在
How could anything be bad for something that doesn't exist?
对于不存在的东西怎么会有坏事情?
So imagining a world in which Shelly exists but Kagan doesn't or Kagan exists but Shelly doesn't, that's trying to imagine a world in which I exist but I don't.
所以想象在一个世界里薛立存在,而卡根不存在或者卡根存在而薛立不存在,这就像是要想象在一个世界里,我存在而我不存在
language, my language ] -what I say and what I think in language--speaks true.] That's the position taken up, not at all the same thing as saying what's out there doesn't exist -nothing to do with that.
那就是,语言,我的语言,说的是真话,这里的语言是指我所说的,以及我用语言所思考的],就是那个立场,与说那里什么东西不存在是完全不同的,与那个没有任何关系。
After all, even if you believe in a soul, as I have remarked previously, that doesn't give us yet any reason to believe the soul continues to exist after the death of your body.
毕竟,就像我之前说过的,即使灵魂是存在的,那也不能说明,灵魂在肉体死后,仍然能继续存在下去
It doesn't mean unicorns exist.
但这并不意味着独角兽就存在
And of course even if in many cases, the engine continues to exist for a while, after the destruction of the car, certainly it doesn't follow the engine is immortal that continues to exist forever.
当然,即使在许多情况下,发动机在汽车毁坏后,能继续存在一段时间,但当然不能得出结论说,发动机是不朽的会永远存在下去。
Still, that's not a world in which the Morning Star doesn't exist, given that what we mean by the Morning Star is that heavenly object, whatever it is, that in this world we pick out at that time in the morning looking up at the sky.
但这并不是意味着,晨星在这个世界不存在,如果给定了晨星的意思就是,一个这样的天体,不管它到底是什么,在这个世界上,在早晨的那个时候我们仰望天空,就能看到的那个天体
If I can tell a story in which A exists and B doesn't exist, it's got to follow that A and B are not the same thing.
如果我跟你说A存在但B不存在,就可以得出结论A和B不是一个东西
you can't imagine a world in which A exists but A doesn't exist.
你无法想象一个A既存在又不存在的世界
This doesn't actually exist in C itself.
这个实际上在C语言本身里是不存在的。
应用推荐