So although I'm trying to sketch the dualist position, as I explained on Tuesday, I don't myself believe in souls.
尽管我在尝试去概述,二元论的观点,就像我在周二所说的,我自己并不相信灵魂
I announced on the first day of class that I don't, myself, believe in the existence of a soul.
第一节课上,我就声明,本人并不相信灵魂的存在
I can't bring myself to believe it, I have some sympathies for valuable container theories, but I also have some sympathy for neutral container theories.
我无法让自己去相信它,我有点赞同有价值容器理论,但是我也有点赞同中性容器理论。
Well--since I myself don't believe in souls, it's hard to surprise you to learn that I don't think the soul theory of personal identity is right.
因为我本身不相信灵魂的存在,所以你们肯定能想到,我认为人格同一性的灵魂论,不是正确的。
So although I don't like, I don't believe the argument is sound-- Premise one doesn't happen to be the premise I myself would want to reject.
尽管我不喜欢,或是我不认为这条论证可靠,但前提一恰是我想要反驳的,它作为前提并非偶然
I can believe in the existence of a meeting that takes place, even though I smuggle myself in as an observer when I picture that meeting.
即便在想象那场会议时,将自己作为观察者带入其中,我仍然相信会议的存在。
It's a way to avoid the argument; although, for what it's worth, I should mention I don't myself believe that it's false that we have free will.
这是回避这条论证的一种方法,尽管这条论证有它自身的价值,应该说,我个人认为,人有自由意志,并没有错
Remind you, that's not to say that I myself do believe that there will be a Judgement Day, and on that day God will reassemble the bodies.
提醒大家,我并不是说,我自己相信,有审判日的到来,那天上帝会重组所有肉体。
I can believe in the possibility of a world without me, even though I smuggle myself in as an observer when I picture that world without me.
即便在设想没有我的世界时,将自己作为观察者带入其中,我还是能相信没有我的世界存在的可能。
From which I think it follows that the mere fact that I've smuggled myself in as an observer doesn't mean that I don't really believe in the possibility that I'm observing in my mind's eye.
我想接下来就是说,仅仅是我将自己作为观察者进入,这一事实并不代表我不相信,我在脑中构建的这种可能性。
Now, bracket the fact that, as I just explained, I don't myself find the argument from recollection persuasive. I don't think we got any good reason to believe based on the sort of things Plato draws our attention to.
我刚刚解释了,我并不觉得源于记忆的论证,有说服力,在柏拉图让我们注意的,这些观点的基础上。
应用推荐