Suppose we rip out my lungs, and put in Johns' lungs, I've gotten a lung transplant, it's still me.
结社我的肺被拿出来,把约翰斯的肺放进去,我接受了肺移植,那还是我。
An old crony and former colleague of mine was taking a course at Johns Hopkins in the 1960s.
我的一个老朋友也是我的大学同学,二十世纪六十年代的时候在约翰斯,霍普金斯大学上学。
If I get a liver transplant, so here I am and we take out my liver and we put Johns' liver inside.
如果我接受了肝脏移植,我的肝脏被拿出来,把约翰斯的肝脏放进去。
suppose we rip out my brain, put in Johns' brain, ? have I gotten a brain transplant?
假设我的大脑被拿走,放进了约翰斯的大脑,我接受的是大脑移植吗?
Horrible accident, Johns' torsel has been destroyed and the left half of his brain has been destroyed, but the right half of the brain is still there.
又是场可怕的车祸,约翰斯的躯干受损,左半脑受损,但右半脑完好。
We take Johns' brain, we put it in Smith's torsel we hook up all the wires as it were, ? the thing wakes up, who is that?
把约翰斯的大脑放进史密斯的躯干,再把各个部位按原样连接好,它醒了,它是谁?
Suppose we rip out my heart and put Johns' heart in here.
假设我的心脏被拿出来,把约翰斯的心脏放进去。
No, what's happened is that Johns has gotten a body transplant.
不,事实是,约翰斯接受了肉体移植。
We take the right half of Johns' brain, put it into Smith's torsel, hook up all the wires the right way, ? the thing wakes up, who is it?
把约翰斯的右半脑,放进史密斯的躯干,按原样连接各个部位,醒来的是谁?
Follow the brain, that's Johns, that woke up.
由大脑决定,醒来的那个是,约翰斯。
Johns' torsel gets destroyed, his brain is fine.
约翰斯的躯干受损,大脑完好。
So there's an accident with Johns and Smith.
假设约翰斯和史密斯发生了车祸。
That will be Johns woke up.
醒来的那个就是约翰斯。
Johns' brain, Smith's torsel.
约翰斯的大脑,史密斯的躯干。
It's Johns.
是约翰斯。
Great! The question was--on this saying, what do we say about the case if we take the two halves of Johns' brain, split them, ? put them into 2 different torsels, they both wake up, ? would they both be Johns?
很好!这个问题是,如果把约翰斯的左右半脑分开,分别放进2个不同的躯干,结果会怎么样,它们都醒了,都会是约翰斯吗?
应用推荐