We need to believe that the soul, unlike an engine, can't itself be destroyed, can't itself decompose, can't fall apart.
我们需要相信的是,灵魂和发动机不同,自己不会毁灭,自己不会腐烂,自己不会变成碎片。
It's the view that probably most of you believe, but again, it's worth noting that philosophically it can be challenged.
这是一种我们大多数人都相信的观点,但是再一次的,需要指出,从哲学讲它是站不住脚的
I believe that and why do we need to have it as a basic premise of the course, '?" as opposed to change is illusive?"
我相信这一点,但为什么我们需要把它,作为课程的基本前提,而不说'改变是虚幻的“
Now I'm not going to hear, pursue of the question of "Do we believe bodily resurrection occurs or will occur?"
现在我不需要,大家一直争论,我们是否要相信,肉体复活是否会发生“
So maybe that's why we need to believe in souls in order to explain free will.
或许我们需要相信灵魂的理由就是,为了便于解释自由意志
Maybe at the end of the day we will decide we need to believe in souls.
或许最终,我们会认定我们需要相信灵魂
We need to distinguish perhaps between what he consciously believes and what he unconsciously believes.
我们需要区别,他有意识地相信和潜意识相信的东西。
And what the physicalist would need to do for each one of those-- For each one of those you can imagine a dualist who says, "We need to believe in a soul so as to explain seances.
对于这些东西,物理主义者该怎么做,对于这些,你可以想到二元论者会说,我们需要相信有灵魂才能解释通灵
应用推荐