Please don't go away thinking that what I just said is, here's a new argument for the soul.
请别就理所当然地想着我刚才说的,觉得灵魂的存在又有了新的论据。
God whips out the old soul, destroys it, puts in a new one with maybe souls only last for a minute and a half.
上帝拿走旧的灵魂,毁掉,注入新的灵魂,那个灵魂可能只产生了一分半钟。
If that happened,we'd have a great new argument for the existence of a soul.
如果两人都醒来,那关于灵魂存在就会有新的争论了。
What if last night God destroyed my soul and put in a new soul?
如果昨晚上帝毁掉了我的灵魂并创造了新的那怎么办?
That's a nice answer to the problem of fission, but notice the problem it raises for the argument for believing in a soul in the first place.
这对于裂变问题是个更好的答案,但请注意这个答案又引起了新的问题,这就是一开始相信灵魂的存在时的说法。
A new soul got created.
一个新的灵魂出现。
If God replaced your soul with a new one destroyed the old one, gave the new one all the old memories, beliefs, desires, goals, and so forth, that person who was in class last week yesterday died.
如果上帝把你的灵魂换了,把旧的毁了,换上新的,换上所有记忆,信仰,追求,目标,还有别的,上星期上课的那个人,昨天就死了。
应用推荐