And here I want to distinguish between the individual question about the inevitability of death, and the universal question.
在这里我要区分,死亡必然性的个人性,以及普遍性。
All right. So I've been talking for, actually now a couple of weeks I suppose, about the central badness of death.
好了,我已经谈了,几个星期,关于死亡的坏处。
And when I asked about philosophy he said philosophy has nothing to say about death, only poetry has something to say about death.
当我问到哲学的时候,他说哲学与死亡无关,只有诗能够解读死亡。
I ought to say a word about death, in order to comprehend what the Greeks thought. You know, different peoples have had different ideas about them.
我得说一下有关死亡的事儿,好让你们更容易理解希腊人的思维,你们知道,不同人对于死亡的观念是不同的
Dying is exactly as I composed it in Death and transfiguration."
死亡和我在净化与死亡中","表现的一模一样"
Have we at least found something interesting,necessary, unique to death when we say,Nobody can die my death for me.
我们是否至少找到一些有趣,必要,独特的东西,当我们说“没有人能代替我死亡。
Well, if normally there's this super tight connection between my soul and my body, death might be the severing of that connection.
如果我的灵魂和肉体之间,有着超紧密的联系,那么死亡就是这种联系的终结
But the explanation of what's bad for me,in his having died, is the fact that it's bad for him to have died.
但他的死亡对我来说不好的地方,却同样也是对他不好的方面。
So again,we don't have any clear, true interpretation of the claim that nobody can take my place, even with regard to dying.
所以我们还是没有一个清晰的,真实的关于没人能取代我的诠释,更不用说死亡了。
I don't think it very relevant whether the death comes about because you withdraw life support, like a ventilator, or because you actually decide to end that child's life by giving the child a lethal injection.
我觉得这也与造成死亡的原因无关,无论是通过撤走维持生命的仪器,比如呼吸机,还是通过药物注射,结束孩子的生命。
There'll be a brief period in which, as a cadaver I suppose, my heart will continue to exist.
在我死亡后很短的时间内,我的心脏将会继续存在
It certainly feels, to my mind, as though it's an extra bad about the nature of death.
当然有这个,在我看来,像是关于死亡本性的另一个坏处。
And there's at least some comfort to be had, isn't there, in the realization that this thing isn't just true for me.
至少这里还有让人感到安慰的事,因为死亡必然性不仅对我来说是真的。
Indeed,let me take a moment and read a poem that emphasizes this thought, because this is certainly one central,very bad thing about death.
事实上,让我念一首诗来强调它,因为这确实是死亡的主要坏处。
In short,even though it's true that nobody can die my death for me, this isn't some deep insight into the special nature of death.
简单地说,即便没人能够经历我的死亡,这也不是关于死亡本质的深刻见地。
Let's suppose that my personality doesn't get destroyed any sooner than the death of my body.
让我们设定我的人格并没有,在肉体的死亡前被破坏。
In the normal case,I die when my body stops functioning, in terms of the body functions.
通常,我在身体停止运作时就死亡了,这说的是在生理功能停止。
That's a little bit misleading, given the view I just sketched where even though I'm dead I still exist for a while as a corpse.
这有一点误导人,根据我刚才阐述的理论,即便我死亡,依然能作为尸体存在一段。
Just before the death scene, there's a long myth, which I draw your attention to but I don't want to discuss in any kind of detail.
我想让你们注意,在这个死亡场景之前,有一个古老的传说,但我不想去讨论任何的细节
Well, the thought, of course, is I can't picture or imagine my death.
当然理由就是,我无法想象我的死亡。
We might say, well, it's not true now Death isn't bad for me now I'm not dead now ? Maybe death is bad for me when I'm dead?
我们可能会说,反正现在不是真的,死亡现在对我来说没有坏处,我现在又没死,也许当我死的时候死亡对我有坏处?
I'd die as soon as I forgot anything at all of what I was doing 20 minutes ago.
只要我忘记20分钟前的事情,也就等于死亡。
Because,of course,if they take my place, they end up living or going through,rather,their death not my death.
因为即便他们代替了我的位置,他们还是经历了自己的死亡,而不是我的。
Let's just suppose that,for the sake of avoiding those complications, that when my body dies,it gets destroyed.
为了避免这些难题,然我们假设,当我的肉体死亡,它就被破坏。
What I primarily have in mind are sort of psychological and sociological questions about the nature of death, or the phenomenon of death.
首先我想到的是一些关于,死亡本质和死亡现象的,一些心理学和社会学的问题。
That's the central badness of death and that's the one I'm going to have us focus on.
这才是死亡的主要坏处,我就将集中讨论这个。
That, as I say, is I think a common set of views about the nature of death.
就像我说的,一个普遍的观点,关于自然死亡。
How should one live, in light of the facts about death ? that I've been laying out in the semester up to this point?
一个人应该怎样活着,鉴于我这个学期一直讲到这刻的,关于死亡的事实?
And as I mentioned earlier then, death is so horrible and life is so wonderful that it could never make sense to throw it away.
当我更早的提及,死亡是可怕的而生活是美好的时,却因为不理解而忽视了。
Maybe my body--I'm imagining my body dead, but I'm not imagining myself, the person, dead.
也许我能想像自己肉体的死亡,但不能想想自己作为个人的死亡。
应用推荐