Pretty clearly, to think about death and continued existence and survival, we have to get clear about the nature of personal identity.
很清楚,要想思考死亡,和继续存在并且活着,我们不得不弄清楚个人身份的本质。
All right,so on the body view,I exist here, but I'm not alive,so it doesn't give me what matters.
好了,在肉体理论角度,我存在于此,但我并不是活着的,这不是我想要的关键。
I don't have what I wanted,when I wanted to survive.
没有我活着时想要的东西。
It's natural to talk that way, but if we want belief in the soul to help us hold out the possibility at least that there might be life after death, then I think we need to actually say that strictly speaking, it's not that a person is a soul plus a body.
这说起来很轻松,如果我们想要寄托于,相信灵魂的存在,而让死后能够继续活着有据可依,那么我们需要一个严格的说法,不是说一个人是灵魂加肉体
应用推荐