So Alpha in this case is better against Alpha, and Beta is better against Beta, but neither dominates each other.
所以对方选α时我应该也选α,她选β我也应该选β,这里没有优势策略
Who would choose Beta? Very few Beta's, but mostly Alpha's. Alpha, I think, is the right answer here but why?
好,谁会选β,很少有选β的,基本都选的是α,α应该是正确答案
A natural question the first week of school is what are you shopping?
开学第一周学生自然会问,应该选哪些课程?
You've got to realize that in calculus, the symbols that you call x and y are completely arbitrary.
你应该明白在微积分中,选x还是y当符号是完全任意的
If these are my payoffs I should go ahead and choose Alpha because that way I end up getting 3.
如果我关心我成绩我应该直接选α,因为那样我能得到3单位效用
Right, so you should all have been choosing in this game, you all should have chosen Alpha.
对,在这次博弈中,你们应该都选α
So in both cases, no matter what the other person does, she receives a higher payoff from choosing Alpha, so she should choose Alpha.
这两种情况下,无论别人怎么选,她选α总能得到更好的成绩,所以她应该选α
I believe the other guy is going to choose Left, I can rationalize choosing Up.
我认为对手应该会选左,这样我认为选上是合理的
And two, even if that was the case I'd do better to myself choose Alpha.
第二,就算上条可行我仍应该选α
So I should choose Beta: 1 is bigger than 0, i should choose Beta.
因此我该选β,1比0大,我应该选β
Even if I could make everyone in the room choose Beta by the force of my brain waves, What should I then do? I should choose Alpha.
就算我能用我脑波强迫,你们选β,那我应该选什么,我应该选α
In the first game, it was kind of clear that we should choose Alpha and here it's not at all clear what we can do-- what we should do.
在第一个博弈里,我们很显然应该选α,但这次我们应该怎么选就很不确定了
Sudiptha had suggested earlier on, you want to be close to 5.
苏蒂帕之前提到过,我们应该选更靠近5的立场
Beta is better against Beta. There's no dominance going on here.
她选β我也应该选β,这次没有优势策略
Write down on your notepad what you should do.
在你笔记本上写下你应该怎么选
Who thinks you should choose Beta in that case?
谁觉得应该选β
Why? Why should you choose Alpha here?
为什么我们这回应该选α呢
What should you do?
你应该怎么选
So certainly part of the problem here, with the reasoning I just gave you-- the reasoning that said I should choose Beta, because if we both reason the same way, we both do better that way-- involves some kind of magical reasoning.
那么说问题就出在了这里,就是之前我们说应该选β的问题,如果我们要都这么想,确实得到更好成绩,但这是有前提的
Good, so even if everyone in the number-- everyone in the room didn't choose randomly but they all chose a 100, a very unlikely circumstance, but even if everyone had chosen 100, the highest, the average, sorry, the highest two-thirds of the average could possibly be is 66 2/3, hence 67 would be a pretty good choice in that case.
好的,如果每个人,教室里的每个人不是随机选择数字,而是全选了100,这好像不太可能,但如果每个人真的都选了100,就是最大的书,那平均数,抱歉,平均数的2/3会是66又2/3,此情况下67应该是个不错的选项
We should defend easy which is what most of you chose.
我们应该防守平坦之途,大多数人都这么选
And once I know that she's going to choose Alpha, it's clear that I should choose Alpha and get 0 rather than Beta and get -3. So I should choose Alpha also.
一旦我意识到她会选α的时候,很显然我应该也选α来得到0单位效用,而不是选β只得到-3,所以我也选α
So what we know here, we know that Player II should not choose right.
从中我们得出参与者II不应该选右
Similarly, for Player II, the lowest Player I could ever do, is choose 0, in which case Player II would want to choose 1, so the strategies below 1 are never a best response for Player II.
同理,参与人I最低只能选0,此时参与人II应该会选1,小于1的策略不是参与人I的最佳对策
应用推荐