He could take our molecules which have been scattered, put them back together, " and say "Ha, that's your body."
他可以收起,我们散落的分子,将它们重组,然后说“看,那是你的肉体“
When they say you don't believe you're going to die, do you mean, you don't believe your body's going to die?
当你说你不相信自己会死,你的意思是不相信肉体的死亡?
Well,if you're prepared to say that, then indeed you will be able to say, yeah,it's the body view.
如果你打算那么说,那你确实可以认为,这是肉体理论。
You might think the answer to that is no if we are physicalists but in fact it's not so clear the answer is no.
如果我们是物理主义者你可能认为,人不可能肉体不死,但其实答案没有那么明确。
It is not all that mysterious how we check out to see whether-- the same body has been around, even though you didn't do it.
究竟我们是如何,检验是否是同样的肉体-,不管你有没有特意去检验,也不像灵魂论那么神秘。
I'd say, look, you're looking at a body, but connected in this intimate way with this body is a particular soul, the soul of Shelly Kagan.
我会说,你看到的是一个肉体,但与肉体最紧密连接的,是特定的一个灵魂,是谢利·凯根的灵魂。
It just lies there; whereas your body, my body is animated.
只是躺在那里,而你我的肉体都是有生命的
That is, you're dead as a person. Previously, we distinguished between the death of my body and my death as a person; let's focus on my death as a person.
这指的是你作为个人的死亡,之前我们已区别了肉体和个人的死亡;,现在我们将重点放在个人的死亡上。
Now,this is the very early stuff when your body's still developing and your brain hasn't turned on yet, or your brain is turned on,but it hasn't actually become a person yet,right?
而这里,你的肉体还在开发中,是大脑还没有完全开智的早期阶段,或者说你还没有完全成为人的阶段?
And then of course we could have further investigate whether-- when you reassemble a body, is it more like the watch case or ? is it more like the tower case?
接着我们才可以,更深入地去研究-,当你重组肉体时,情况是更接近手表这个案例,还是搭积木塔这个案例?
If you can figure out which one is you, that would tell you whether you think the body theory is the right theory or the personality theory is the right theory.
如果你能想清楚,你就能想清楚到底,肉体论是对的,还是人格论是对的。
Here's the existence of your body.
这是你的肉体存在。
I would say if you make out of my bodies molecules or a category like that then that's not my body, but if you put them together in a right way, that seems to be like--should be my body.
如果你将我的肉体,将我原来的分子重组的话,那并不是我的肉体,只有当你以原来的次序重组时,那个才会是我的肉体。
应用推荐