There is a wide variation around the index return which at the tail can be devastating.

FORBES: Playing With Active Money Managment Is A Losing Game

That same concept can be dropped into cataloging, where even in the old days, when librarians described books within the boundaries of a physical index card, great variation still occurred.

FORBES: The Search for a Concise and All-Encompassing Library Record

The remaining 10% of funds that outperformed the index can be attributed to chance variation since they did not consistently outperform over several years.

FORBES: Cheating The Random Walk