Yet this theory might explain how a fight between Sam and Amy, and not Seth and Amy, had left Seth dead.

NEWYORKER: A Loaded Gun

When Sam and Amy came to see me, they were bleeding money.

FORBES: Losing And Winning: A Success Story

Sam and Amy have gone two years since they made their shift.

FORBES: Losing And Winning: A Success Story

That said, they still ended up having about 31 musicians involved, including appearances from Leslie Feist, Emily Haines, Amy Millan, The Sea and Cake's Sam Prekop and more.

NPR: Broken Social Scene: Leaner Lineup, Same Big Sound

That evening, Amy was released from the police station, and Judy and Sam took her home.

NEWYORKER: A Loaded Gun

There is a good reason that Sam and Judy Bishop would be uncomfortable with such a timeline: in their telling, Amy took out the shotgun in the first place because she had been home alone for several hours.

NEWYORKER: A Loaded Gun