Liberal Democrat Ross Finnie called for clarity over rapid response vehicles and staffing problems.
Her amendment fell at decision time, as did the amendment from the Liberal Democrat health spokesman Ross Finnie.
Fisheries Minister Ross Finnie said such a move would be "an unacceptably blunt instrument not justified by the science".
BBC: NEWS | UK | Scotland | Experts urge radical fishing ban
Scotland's rural affairs minister, Ross Finnie, has so far resisted calls for an inquiry made by two Scottish parliamentary committees.
ECONOMIST: Pressure is mounting to do something about salmon farms
And Ms Sturgeon agreed with Liberal Democrat Ross Finnie that the health board's response to the problem as "very unhelpful".
Rural Development Minister Ross Finnie hailed the bill as "a progressive and reforming piece of legislation" which illustrated the value of devolution.
For the Liberal Democrats, Ross Finnie saw his amendment carried unanimously.
Liberal Democrat health spokesman Ross Finnie said the Health Committee had been "hampered" in its efforts to scrutinise the legislation without a specific minimum unit price.
For the Liberal Democrats, Ross Finnie insisted a sustainable model for Scotland's housing strategy was required and a much changed housing structure must reflect the impact of the recession.
Liberal Democrat health spokesman Ross Finnie said the health secretary was being "naive" if she thought her decision to keep the emergency unit open would not jeopardise other services.
BBC: NEWS | UK | Scotland | Glasgow and West | A&E decision halts cancer centre
But Scottish Liberal Democrat health spokesman Ross Finnie said he was concerned that the government had made the announcement before the health boards had a chance to bring forward alternative proposals.
BBC: NEWS | UK | Scotland | A&E closure decisions overturned
应用推荐