But peers agreed by a 21-vote majority to remove the relevantclause from the Crime and Courts Bill, during report stage of the legislation on 27 November 2012.
It is extraordinary how many non-lawyers can name (and intelligently discuss) the relevant Commerce Clause precedents, such as Wickard, Raich, Lopez and Morrison.
He is now calling for a "reasonableness" clause to be introduced to the act so that any request for information has to be reasonable and relevant to the workings of a council.