Before excoriating me for my own cynicism, I would defend by pointing out that the GOP has earned my questioningapproach given the track record they have built in taking so many cynical steps that do the public harm for their own advancement.
It is, therefore, not at all uncommon for Justices to take a very contrary or aggressive approach in their questioning only to later hand down a decision that goes in a very different direction than what might have been reasonably anticipated based on the questioning session.