Mr McCarthy was brought in specifically to improve the schools' results but stressed that it was very much a team effort, driven by the slogan "good teaching is notgood enough".
Yet teaching in secondary schools "is still not as good as other subjects, and for the 16 to 18-year-old range, the proportion of good or better specialist teaching of ICT is low", the QCA said.
Teaching unions and head teachers have said phonics is a good way of teaching children to read but say it is not a magic formula and different children may require different approaches.
But inspectors warned that GCSE teaching focused on achieving good exam results and that this did not always prepare pupils for study at a more advanced level.
The Department for Education said free schools will provide all children - not just the rich - the opportunity to go to a good school with great teaching, strong discipline and small class sizes.
While insisting she was not advocating a "soft and fluffy" style of teaching, she argued that research showed that a good teacher had to engage with "the powerfully charged emotional relationship between teacher and pupil".