My review confirmed significant methodological differences in the database query specified by Hauser and St.

FORBES: Guest Post: After an Unprecedented Request for a Retraction, A Close Look at the Data

He really DID review the report and found HUNDREDS of serious methodological errors.

FORBES: A Tennessee Fireman's Solution to Climate Change

Their aim is to achieve highest scientific standards by carrying out a rigorous peer review that is, as a minimum requirement, supposed to be able to identify fundamental methodological errors or false claims.

FORBES: Editor Resigns Over Global Warming Paper, Blames