With Matthew Lillard, who camps it up as a straight shoe salesman.

NEWYORKER: Wicker Park

With Matthew Lillard, Adrian Lester, Natascha McElhone, and Alicia Silverstone, who bravely tackles the Shakespearean pentameter as if she were being asked to eat cactus.

NEWYORKER: Love's Labour's Lost

Before the crash, she was cheating on him with a real-estate agent named Brian Speer (Matthew Lillard), and, though Matt confronts her in the hospital, ranting vainly at her motionless form, what he really yearns to do is meet Brian, face to face.

NEWYORKER: Better Times