Two of the Law Lords agreed with Lord Bingham's reasoning in the lower court.
The case is listed to be heard by the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Bingham, Mr Justice Alliott and Mr Justice Newman.
Look, whoever wins will want to do their best for Oxford and Lord Bingham and Lord Neil have got great records of service to Oxford already.
Because he cannot be tried for crimes in a British court, claimed Lord Bingham, he cannot be extradited to Spain, a basic principle of most extradition agreements.
Then the first panel of five Law Lords, hearing an appeal of Lord Bingham's decision, found by 3-2 that former heads of state did not enjoy immunity for heinous international crimes.
The accusations against General Pinochet, Lord Bingham decided, refer to actions taken as head of state, not in a personal capacity, and therefore he continues to enjoy immunity from prosecution for them.
They quoted the late Lord Bingham, who said in a 2005 judgement that such evidence was "unreliable, unfair, offensive to ordinary standards of humanity and decency and incompatible with the principles which should animate a tribunal seeking to administer justice".
Lord Bingham, and one of the Law Lords in the first panel who sided with General Pinochet, considered the retrospectivity argument briefly, and then rejected it because the plain language of Britain's 1989 Extradition Act seems explicitly to rule it out.
Lord Bingham concluded that a former head of state enjoys immunity as well because one English statute confers on a head of state the same legal protections as those enjoyed by an ambassador, which a second statute spells out as including immunity for official acts during his tenure as an ambassador even after he has left his post.
The Lords overturned a judgment by Thomas Bingham, Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, sitting as head of a three-judge panel in Britain's High Court.
That was the view taken last October by Thomas Bingham, Lord Chief Justice, sitting in the High Court, and then the following month by two Law Lords in the minority on the first panel to hear the appeal.
First Thomas Bingham, the Lord Chief Justice, found that the general enjoyed absolute immunity for any crime.
"Instructions were to make arrangements for John Bingham, also known as Lord Lucan, to see his children and to do that I had to book his two eldest children on flights to Africa, " she said.
应用推荐