Alonso survived 13 laps before he came back to the pits to revert to slicks but a problem with a loosewheel nut saw him trapped in the pits for 18 seconds leaving him short on time to close down Schumacher.
Button's disappointing season continued when he failed to finish in the points after being sent out from his final pit stop with a loose front wheel, having been fifth at one stage.
"It is possible that with an old, not properly maintained fifth wheel that the device can get loose, the sides can wear away, the hole that the pin fits into is no longer snug and rigid, " Scott said.