He achieved his primary goal of keeping the club in the top flight but would have achieved that aim a lot easier if Sunderland had shown the same sort of endeavour, energy and enthusiasm as they did for the most part against Chelsea.

BBC: Sunderland 2-3 Chelsea

Calderwood was brought in to replace Jim Jefferies in January and given the mandate of keeping the Ayrshire side in Scotland's top flight.

BBC: Manager Jimmy Calderwood may not stay at Kilmarnock