"I'd vote for Josiah Bartlet, " wrote Nancy Harris, of Red Wing, Minnesota, responding to a CNN message board.

CNN: A presidential sheen

She isn't at all surprised that many voters say they'd choose Josiah Bartlet over Al Gore or George W. Bush.

CNN: A presidential sheen

He scores a second president on our list: Josiah Bartlet.

FORBES: Bill Pullman In 'Independence Day' Tops Our List Of The Best Fictional Presidents

"I have a couple of friends, and we wish that when we go to vote, we could just write in 'Josiah Bartlet' for president, " said a "West Wing" fan from South Carolina as she stood outside the White House in Washington.

CNN: A presidential sheen