-
The conditional nature of CVRs makes them valuable in breaking logjams in price negotiations.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
After all, CVRs are only payable upon the occurrence of some milestone event by a future date.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
Essentially, CVRs are derivatives whose value is tied to future events, such as product performance or revenue targets.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
CVRs can transfer much of the risk normally borne by acquirers to the shareholders in the target corporation.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
The most troubling aspect of CVRs from an investor standpoint, however, is the way the instruments redistribute risk in deals.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
For one thing, the fact that the value of CVRs is largely dependent on future events presents challenging taxation and accounting issues.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
After the financial crisis vastly amplified market volatility, CVRs began to play an increasing role in many mergers and acquisitions, especially in the risk-laden biotech and pharmaceutical sectors.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
CVRs do have some downsides for investors, however.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
Although some CVRs are registered tradable securities, the majority are non-transferable because the issuing company does not want to incur the additional cost, disclosure obligations, and legal responsibilities associated with registering them with the SEC.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
While there is no doubt that CVRs can effectively circumvent arguments about current value, in the wake of a financial crisis fueled by risky and speculative financial instruments, investors are right to be wary of the unknown.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights
-
If the IRS follows the same rule for event-type CVRs, the issuer recognizes no gain or loss on the CVR issuance, the repurchase of the CVR, or the lapse of the CVR, but a target shareholder generally must recognize an immediate capital gain or loss taking into consideration the fair market value of the CVRs received on the date of distribution.
FORBES: Shadowy Shares: The Dark Side of Contingent Value Rights