It's a proposal that is fundamentally at odds with the conservativeprinciple of individual responsibility, and is the latest in a string of public spats conservatives have had over the years and in this election with their party's standard bearer.
Just as enforcing personal morality seems to be a unifying principle behind many conservative appeals for government interventionism, liberals seem to be driven by a desire to reverse perceived power imbalances.
Scottish Conservative leader Annabel Goldie asked if the first minister accepted the principle of a graduate contribution to help fund higher education.
However British Conservative MEP Sajjad Karim said he supported the new regulation in principle, and hoped that further negotiations could take place over the claw-back issue.
After two terms as governor, Reagan had matured into what Buckley considered a nearly ideal conservative politician: a shrewd leader as well as a man of principle.
But appearing on the same programme, Conservative MP Kwasi Kwarteng accused Labour of "playing parliamentary games" rather than acting out of principle.