The senior judge said that when O'Connor was asked by an officer for his details he began to give "a wrong and misleading name" and pushed past and ran off.
Chief Superintendent David O'Connor from the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents also echoed this concern and asked whether the members of the board should be full time posts.
Following the appeal judges' decision advocate depute Ashley Edwards asked them to re-impose the community payback order on O'Connor, which had been suspended.