Actually the latter was effectively cheaper, because the winning bidder at auction typically pays an additional charge to the auction house, called a buyer's premium, that can range from 15% to 18%.

WSJ: A Guide to Bidding in Online Wine Auctions | On Wine by Lettie Teague

The remainder of the investment charge was related to holdings the company had in auction-rate securities.

FORBES: AMD Stands Behind ATI, Write-Downs And All