The problem with these investigations is not simply that the FTC so often gravitates toward market definitions that are unduly narrow, making it easier to establish antitrust injury while failing to capture market realities.
FORBES: Don't Throw The Flag: How The FTC Acts Like Replacement Refs
As long as Google maintains its strong market position, antitrust gripes are going to keep hounding it.
Any antitrust expert will tell you it is dangerous to compare antitrust cases across time and market space.
FORBES: Understanding Internet Competition: Why All High Tech Markets Are Not Equal
He said he doubted that Apple, currently, has a sufficiently dominant position in that market to warrant antitrust scrutiny.
WSJ: Apple Antitrust Issues Raised by Subscription-Service Terms
At the extreme, too much market power creates antitrust problems for hospital systems.
On Friday morning, Intel revealed it had received a subpoena from the U.S. Federal Trade Commission probing antitrust violations in the microprocessor market.
But a collective agreement meant to set broad market conditions crosses antitrust lines, and the Department of Justice sued Apple and the five publishers in April of this year.
ENGADGET: Editorial: Bring on the digital overthrow of publishing
The deal, which is subject to regulatory approval, comes less than a year after the European Commission rejected a merger proposal between Deutsche Boerse (DB) and NYSE Euronext on the grounds of antitrust concerns in the derivatives market.
FORBES: Asia The Next Frontier For Stock Exchange Consolidation
Wherever there is market power, the antitrust authorities have reason to be watchful.
But as the market continues to change, antitrust interventions are stuck using a static regulatory framework.
FORBES: Correcting Herb Kohl (And Kayak And Bing Travel ...) On Google/ITA
With 56% of the American gum market, Wrigley would hit antitrust problems.
Historically, antitrust enforcers tried to shield competitors from market-dominant companies that could crush them through price cutting, intimidation of suppliers, or other dubious tactics.
The market-based approach to antitrust regulation, popularised by Aaron Director of the University of Chicago, holds that antitrust violations must be ripping someone off, whether a customer or a supplier.
Since the merger raises no antitrust issues in the U.S. market, security concerns are likely to be the main focus of federal authorities reviewing the merger.
Cantor acknowledges the importance of the goal, but says insurers need to do it themselves, without the help of intermediaries who might have enough market power to cross the line into antitrust.
FORBES: $11 Million Verdict Shows Dangers Of Medical Cost Control
Underwriters also form syndicates to share the risk of bringing a new company to market--evidence of illegal collusion under antitrust laws?
Now, antitrust practitioners view how a monopolist came to dominate a market and whether it obstructs competitors in a way that hurts consumers in exerting its monopolistic power.
"Even the most conservative antitrust people I know think you need at least three market players to have competition, " says Scott Cleland, an analyst with communications research firm the Precursor Group.
When pharmacy benefit management (PBM) companies Express Scripts and Medco announced their merger on 21 July 2011, the stock market was not optimistic about the companies obtaining antitrust approval from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC).
FORBES: How Medco Won Antitrust Approval For A Deal Wall Street Considered Doomed
This level of futures market power evidently is not of concern to the Antitrust Division.
" Millions will be spent litigating how broad the market is, " said Herbert Hovenkamp, an antitrust professor at the University of Iowa College of Law.
WSJ: Apple Antitrust Issues Raised by Subscription-Service Terms
If Apple is using its existing iTunes leverage to force exclusive arrangements, which likely will give it durable market power, it may well be violating the antitrust laws.
FORBES: Will Apple iCloud Bring An Antitrust Litigation Storm?
But its grip is loosening, thanks to some plucky foreign upstarts, a looming antitrust claim filed by a competitor and a misjudgment of the market's appetite for popular video-game slots.
At the end of the day, antitrust laws are only meant to punish businesses that intentionally dominate the market through misconduct.
FORBES: Does American Needle Case Apply To Collegiate Licensing?
Deutsche Telekom concluded that it would not counter-bid for O2 in part because of fears of antitrust action arising from its own big presence in the German mobile market.
Market dominance arising solely from innovation is therefore virtually unassailable under the antitrust laws.
FORBES: Will Apple iCloud Bring An Antitrust Litigation Storm?
However, some antitrust enforcers say that if they wait until a tech company has cornered a market it may be too late.
Those that can do it without setting off the antitrust alarm of regulators should be thinking this way, especially if too little market power is concentrated in too many hands.
Microsoft underwent its Internet epiphany and successfully clobbered Netscape, grabbing the lead in the browser market, albeit at the cost of setting in motion the biggest antitrust action for a generation.
Until the antitrust lawsuit the company was unfettered in the laissez-faire U.S. market.
应用推荐