Anerrorofjudgment cost him his wicket to the final ball before lunch as he pushed at a wide one from Batty and slip fielder Marcus Trescothick accepted the chance at the second attempt.
Purists argue that implementing instant replay and removing human error and judgment would take away an element that is as much a part of the game as anything else.
It may also be a minor errorofjudgment on Mr Rogan's part to have relied so heavily on Hassanein Heikal, an Egyptian journalist, for his account of Anwar Sadat.