If we take 2010 aggregate company unit shipments and addtheunit shipments of Seagate to Samsung and Western Digital to HGST, we find the combinations should have resulted in about 41% unit share for Seagate plus Samsung, 48% unit share for Western Digital plus Hitachi GST and 11% unit share for Toshiba.
Two years later they lobbied the state legislature to allow them to add a recovery ward, X-ray unit and kitchen to convert the surgery center into a hospital.
I've got nothing to add to the report of the independent person who looks at policies on behalf of the Public Appointments Unit which concluded that the appointment was a proper one.