The system is guaranteed to produce a less-qualified work force than simply picking the highest scorers, but it was used for years in the New York Police Department, until the Giuliani administration abolished it in the mid-1990s.

FORBES: Quota? What's That?

Administration officials charged that the Port Authority Police Department was incompetent.

WSJ: Candidate for Mayor Apologizes for Comment About Port Authority Police

Since then, he has run four police departments, as well as the Justice Department's Office of Community Policing during the Clinton administration.

WSJ: White House Czar Calls for End to 'War on Drugs'