Schultenfirst hypothesized in 1978 that some sort of biochemicalreactiontook placein birds’ eyes, mostlikelyproducingelectronswhose spinwas affected bysubtlemagneticgradients.
The authors Alison Fromme, Jennifer Cutraro and Katherine Schulten (who have no expertise in this area and little combined science reporting experience) make the prejudicial choice of focusing almost exclusively on the controversy rather than on the broad issue in all its glory and warts adopting, as did Ian Urbina, the narrative of the shale gas critics.