Jeffrey Kovar, assistant legal adviser for the U.S. State Department, who has been representing the U.S. in these ongoing negotiations, testified in a June House subcommittee hearing that the "widening gap" between global commerce and individual court systems could inhibit growth in trade.
CNN: Technology - Yahoo! opens legal can of worms with sale of Nazi-related items
However, when we move to fields such as commerce, progressives stop trusting individual decision-making, probably because they do not understand the world of commerce themselves.
FORBES: Are Progressives Too Conservative to Accept Capitalism?
Instead it reflects my view as to whether the individual mandate is constitutional under the Commerce Clause.
FORBES: The Economics of the Mandate Don't Matter: It's Constitutional
The federal government argues the individual mandate is constitutional under the Commerce Clause, which allows Congress to regulate interstate commerce.
FORBES: The Economics of the Mandate Don't Matter: It's Constitutional
But that disqualification from an economic activity is worlds apart from an individual mandate, especially since the Commerce Clause argument is couched in terms of economic liberties, anyhow.
That clarity likewise characterizes two separate decisions by conservative federal appellate judges Laurence Silberman and Jeffrey Sutton who upheld the individual mandate as a penalty under the Commerce Clause.
Having held that the individual insurance requirement was unconstitutional under the Commerce Clause, the fate of Obamacare rested on whether the mandate could be imposed as part of the taxing powers afforded to Congress.
"Personal income in November and December was boosted by accelerated and special dividend payments to persons and by accelerated bonus payments and other irregular pay in private wages and salaries in anticipation of changes in individual income tax rates, " the Commerce Department's Bureau of Economic Analysis said.
Therefore, the individual mandate constitutes the regulation of participation in commerce that is inevitable.
FORBES: Free Market Rules Don't Work In Delivering Health Care
These actions are a clear exercise of the individual rights of the restaurant owner to do commerce with whom she wishes on a voluntary basis with terms mutually agreeable to both parties.
FORBES: Universal Health Insurance Mandates, And The Emergency Care Myth
The individual inactivity argument does not just apply to the Commerce Clause claim.
Judge Boyce Martin, a Carter appointee and Judge Jeffrey Sutton, a George W. Bush appointee, upheld the individual mandate of the Act under Congress's Commerce Clause power.
Another individual purportedly stole identities from a local Chamber of Commerce and arranged to be paid in those names, as well as in the names of friends and relatives.
FORBES: Adult Basketball League Referees Plead Guilty To Income Tax Fouls
In my humble view, however, the individual mandate oversteps the bounds of regulation contemplated by the Commerce Clause.
Civil liberties advocates and many companies resolutely oppose the plan, saying it is unworkable, an infringement on individual privacy and destined to stunt the growth of electronic commerce.
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote from the liberal side of the bench, urging the court to uphold the Act in its entirety and rejecting the Roberts view that the individual mandate exceeds the power of Congress to regulate interstate commerce.
"The Commerce Clause is not a general license to regulate an individual from cradle to grave, simply because he will predictably engage in particular transactions, " the chief justice wrote.
The narrow focus of the ruling on key issues like the individual mandate -- limiting it to taxing powers rather than general commerce -- represented an effort by the court to limit the government's authority.
CNN: Emotions high after Supreme Court upholds health care law
The individual intrastate farmer is performing an economic activity that has a connection to interstate commerce.
FORBES: The Economics of the Mandate Don't Matter: It's Constitutional
Unlike many forms of financial commerce, insurance is not regulated at the federal level but by individual states.
On Thursday, however, Chief Justice Roberts drew a firm limit on the commerce power, writing that if accepted as the basis of the individual insurance mandate, federal authority would be virtually unlimited.
The meat of the case concerns the challenge to the individual mandate, which the justices could decide oversteps Congress' right to regulate interstate commerce.
This elegant Commerce Clause argument generates, however, several odd implications about both federalism and individual rights.
The consitutional issue in the Obamacare individual mandate cases is all about how far Congress can push its power under the Interstate Commerce Clause.
FORBES: Middle District of Pennsylvania Rules Three Obamacare Provisions Unconstitutional
The court found that the individual insurance mandate at the heart of the law was not enforceable under Congress' power over interstate commerce but rather as a tax.
Every economic decision an individual makes, when aggregated with the economic decisions of everyone else, combines to substantially affect interstate commerce in the way the federal government is asserting here.
FORBES: ObamaCare and the Constitution Are Contradictory: One Must Fall
应用推荐