Andriy Pyatov saved Ibrahim Afellay's shot as the visitors eased through 1-0.

BBC: Shakhtar 0-1 Barcelona (agg 1-6)

While Spurs regrouped after that second substitution, Ibrahim Afellay came close to giving PSV with the lead when his shot was beaten away by Robinson.

BBC: PSV 0-1 Tottenham (1-1)

But the second half followed much the same pattern as the first, and Ibrahim Afellay should have made it 2-0 when he sliced wide from 20 yards.

BBC: Tottenham 0-1 PSV